Rule 196 explained: this guide covers what it means, who it applies to, the step-by-step process, documents required, fees, due dates and penalties in India — so you can stay compliant with confidence and avoid costly mistakes.
Rule 196 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026 constitutes a three-member Dispute Resolution Committee for every Principal Chief Commissioner region — two retired IRS officers and one serving ex-officio member — and rule 197 puts the application in Form No. 119 with a Rs 1,000 fee.
What rule 196 constitutes
Sub-rule (1) of rule 196: the Central Government shall constitute a Dispute Resolution Committee for every region of Principal Chief Commissioner of Income-tax for dispute resolution, as provided under section 379. The unit is the region, not the state and not the country — so the Committee an assessee goes to follows the Principal Chief Commissioner region his case sits in. The 1962 parallel is rule 44DAA.
The three seats
Sub-rule (2) fixes the composition of every Committee constituted under rule 196 at exactly three:
| Seat | Who fills it under rule 196(2) | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Retired members | Retired officers from the Indian Revenue Service (Income-tax) who have held the post of Commissioner of Income-tax or any equivalent or higher post for five years or more | Two |
| Ex-officio member | An officer not below the rank of Principal Commissioner of Income-tax or Commissioner of Income-tax, as specified by the Board | One |
Read the retired-member qualification carefully. It is not "retired Commissioner". It is five years or more at Commissioner level or above — the tenure is a qualifying condition in its own right, and an officer who retired shortly after promotion to Commissioner does not meet it.
The arithmetic in rule 196 is deliberate. Sub-rule (5) says the decision shall be by majority, and the majority is two. Because two of the three seats are held by retired officers with no continuing departmental line, the serving ex-officio member cannot carry a decision alone. That is the structural answer to the obvious objection that a revenue-constituted committee would simply agree with the revenue.
Tenure, fee and removal
| Matter | Provision in rule 196 |
|---|---|
| Appointment | By the Central Government, sub-rule (3) |
| Period | Three years, sub-rule (3) |
| Remuneration | The Central Government may fix a sum to be paid as fee to the two retired members on a per case basis, along with a sitting fee so decided by the Board, sub-rule (4) |
| Decision | By majority, sub-rule (5) |
| Removal | By the Central Government, for reasons to be recorded in writing and after giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard, sub-rule (6) |
Note that sub-rule (4) of rule 196 covers only the members specified in sub-rule (2)(a) — the two retired officers. The ex-officio member is a serving officer drawing a salary and is not paid per case.
Removal under sub-rule (6) carries two safeguards and no stated grounds: the reasons must be recorded in writing and the member must be heard. Neither is a formality — a removal that skips either is open to challenge on the face of rule 196 itself.
Rule 197 — the application
Where rule 196 builds the forum, rule 197 supplies the door. Sub-rule (1): an application to the Dispute Resolution Committee shall be made in Form No. 119 by the person who —
- opts for dispute resolution under section 379;
- does so in respect of a dispute arising from any variation in the specified order in his case; and
- fulfils the specified conditions.
Sub-rule (2): every application shall be accompanied by a fee of Rs 1,000. The 1962 parallel is rule 44DAB.
Both expressions in rule 197 are defined in rule 199, which governs rules 196 to 198. An adviser reading rule 197 alone cannot tell whether a client is eligible: the monetary ceilings (a variation not exceeding Rs 10 lakh and returned total income not exceeding Rs 50 lakh on a section 398 order), the search, survey and treaty-information exclusions, and the five conduct conditions all sit in rule 199. Read the two together.
Worked example
| Facts | Position under rule 196 and rule 197 |
|---|---|
| Assessee's case falls in the Pr. CCIT (Mumbai) region | He goes to the Committee constituted for that region under rule 196(1) |
| A proposed member retired as Commissioner after three years in the grade | Not qualified — rule 196(2)(a) requires five years or more |
| A serving Additional Commissioner is proposed as ex-officio member | Not qualified — the rank must be not below Principal Commissioner or Commissioner |
| Two members favour relief, the third does not | Relief carries — the decision is by majority |
| Government wishes to remove a member mid-term | Permissible, but only with written reasons and a hearing |
| Application filed on plain paper with a covering letter | Defective — rule 197 requires Form No. 119 |
| Form No. 119 filed without the fee | Defective — Rs 1,000 must accompany every application |
| Applicant fails a rule 199 specified condition | Ineligible — rule 197 admits only a person who fulfils them |
Compliance checklist
- Identify the Principal Chief Commissioner region, because that fixes which Committee under rule 196 hears the case.
- Confirm the variation arises from a specified order as defined in rule 199.
- Test the applicant against all five specified conditions in rule 199 before filing.
- File in Form No. 119 — no other format is contemplated.
- Pay the Rs 1,000 fee and keep proof with the application.
- Expect a majority decision from a three-member bench, not a unanimous one.
- Remember the Committee's three-year constitution when a matter is likely to run long.
- Read rule 196, rule 197, rule 198 and rule 199 as a single scheme — none of them is self-contained.
Common mistakes
- Assuming one national Committee instead of one per Pr. CCIT region.
- Reading "retired Commissioner" as the qualification and missing the five-year tenure in rule 196(2)(a).
- Expecting a unanimous decision when the rule provides for a majority.
- Filing without the Rs 1,000 fee.
- Testing eligibility from rule 197 alone when the definitions sit in rule 199.
- Treating the ex-officio member as entitled to a per-case fee — sub-rule (4) covers only the retired members.
Which year this governs
The Income-tax Rules, 2026 are made under the Income-tax Act, 2025 and carry the rule numbering used above. Where a 1962 parallel exists it is given for tracing only — here rule 44DAA for rule 196 and rule 44DAB for rule 197. Verify the current text before acting on a live matter.
