The principle of equal pay for equal work is a fundamental right under Article 14 and 39(d) of the Constitution of India. The Equal Remuneration Act 1976 operationalized this for the workplace. With the Code on Wages 2019, the ERA provisions have been consolidated, strengthening the framework.
Constitutional Basis
- Article 14: Right to equality — no discrimination by the state
- Article 39(d): Directive Principle — state shall ensure equal pay for equal work for men and women
- Supreme Court cases: Randhir Singh v Union of India (1982) — equal pay for equal work is a right; State of MP v Pramod Bhartiya (1993) — applied to public sector
Key Provisions — Equal Remuneration Act 1976 / Code on Wages 2019
Section 4 ERA / Section 3 Code on Wages — Equal Remuneration
- No employer shall pay wages to a woman at a rate less than those paid to a man for the same work or work of a similar nature
- Applies to all remuneration components: basic wage, dearness allowance, and all allowances
- Not limited to factories — applies to all establishments
Section 5 ERA — No Discrimination in Recruitment
- Prohibition on discrimination against women in:
- Recruitment and selection
- Promotion, training, and transfers
- Exception: Where employment of women is prohibited by law (hazardous processes, night shifts in certain industries prior to 2020 relaxation)
Definition of "Same Work or Work of Similar Nature"
Courts have interpreted broadly:
- Work in which the skill, effort, responsibility required, and conditions under which it is performed are substantially similar
- Minor differences in designation (e.g., "clerk" vs "clerk-typist") do not justify different pay if actual duties are same
- Assessment is on actual job content, not labels
- Industry-wide comparisons: applicable within the same establishment, not across industries
Employer Obligations Under ERA / Code on Wages
- Maintain registers: worker-wise wages paid, gender-wise breakup
- Display notices: equal remuneration policy at workplace
- Advisory Committee: every employer with 20+ women must constitute an advisory committee with women members to advise on employment opportunities and conditions
- Not advertise positions for male-only or female-only without legal basis
Practical Scenarios
| Scenario | ERA Implication |
|---|---|
| Male engineer paid Rs.80,000; female engineer same role paid Rs.70,000 | Violation — must equalize immediately |
| Male security guard paid more due to night duty | Different work conditions — differential may be justified |
| Female employee denied promotion because of maternity leave taken | Violation of Sections 5 ERA + Maternity Benefit Act + Article 14 |
| Job advertisement: "Only male candidates" | Violation unless job specifically exempted by law |
Global Context — Equal Pay Laws
- India ratified ILO Convention 100 (Equal Remuneration Convention, 1951)
- Global gender pay gap: approximately 20% worldwide (ILO 2023)
- India's NFHS and World Economic Forum Gender Gap Index measure workforce pay parity progress
- SEBI mandated gender diversity disclosures by listed companies in annual reports
Need Expert Help?
Our CA and legal experts at TaxClue are ready to assist you with compliance, filings, and advisory.
Get Free Consultation